Sorting Out the System
How Humber Polytechnic lifted waste diversion from 31% to 39% in one year by treating waste as a facilities system.
By Tessa Soltendieck and Livia Valpassos
A recycling station can have clear labels and still fail. A compost program can look effective on paper while contaminated material continues to arrive at the loading dock.
This gap between planning and daily operations has guided Humber Polytechnic’s waste diversion work since 2019. Humber established its sustainability goals, while its sustainability, facilities, and food service teams worked with BEST Service Pros to turn those goals into practical routines across the campus.
The results show meaningful progress. Across eight buildings with complete reports for both 2024 and 2025, Humber’s combined diversion rate increased from 31% to 39%. The amount of material diverted from landfill grew by 119 metric tonnes, a 42% increase in one year. Seven buildings improved, one remained steady, and none declined.
The most valuable lesson, however, was not a single percentage. It was learning how to identify the right action for each building.
Waste Diversion Is a System, Not a Bin
Waste diversion involves much more than bins and signs. It depends on several connected factors:
- Whether the right collection streams are available
- Where containers are located
- How material moves through a building
- How occupants sort their waste
- How custodial employees respond to contamination
- How observations and data reach the people who can improve the process
Each group has a role. Occupants make sorting decisions. Facilities teams manage containers, routes, and collection services. Custodial team members handle the material and see problems as they happen. Waste contractors record and report the results.
If one part of this system is missing, the diversion rate can easily be misunderstood.
Start with the People Closest to the Work
Custodial team members see the waste system at its most revealing point. They know which stations confuse occupants, which streams are regularly contaminated, where containers overflow, and where collection routes do not match the way a building is used.
For this reason, training the full custodial team became a priority. The training connected sorting instructions to daily collection practices and focused on the common problems found in different types of buildings.
The program also created a way for frontline observations to reach BEST managers and Humber’s sustainability team. The goal was simple: when a team member noticed a recurring issue, the information needed to reach someone who could improve the station, service, or process.
“Humber’s success in waste management has come from building strong relationships and trust between all parties on campus that have a hand in reducing waste, improving diversion, and advancing our sustainability goals. When priorities align, staff training is more effective, and employees feel empowered to share on-the-ground insights, creating a feedback loop that strengthens and continuously improves the waste management system,” says Tessa Soltendieck, Sustainability Manager at Humber Polytechnic.
This feedback is essential because a campus is not one uniform environment. Offices, residences, food service areas, and receiving facilities generate different materials and face different challenges. Training needs a consistent foundation, but it must also reflect the reality of each location.
Redesign the Routine, Not Just the Sign
Training was supported by operational changes. Building audits showed what was actually entering each waste stream. Humber and BEST then adjusted signage, sorting arrangements, and collection practices where needed.
Some changes focused on preventing waste before it entered the system. At Humber’s International Graduate School, an office pilot replaced paired desk-side waste and recycling bins with a desk-side recycling bin and centralized sorting stations. Employees brought residual waste to the shared stations. This reduced the use of plastic liners and made sorting a more visible, personal action.
Food service initiatives also introduced reusable containers. At the North Campus residence café, an internal observation found that waste decreased from about 60 pounds to about 20 pounds during one initiative. This was an operational observation rather than a formal audit result, so it should be understood as an indication of progress, not a verified outcome.
What the Results Show
The eight buildings with complete reports for both 2024 and 2025 provide the fairest comparison.
| Measure | 2024 | 2025 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Combined diversion rate | 31% | 39% | +8 points |
| Diverted material | 283 tonnes | 402 tonnes | +119 t (42%) |
| Total reported material | 903 tonnes | 1,043 tonnes | +16% |
| Material sent to landfill | 620 tonnes | 640 tonnes | +3% |
| Seven of the eight buildings improved their diversion rate, one held steady and none declined. Tonnes are metric tonnes. | |||
These figures show why tonnage matters as much as the diversion rate. Humber managed a 16% increase in total reported material while keeping the increase in landfilled material to only 3%. About 85% of the additional material entered diverted streams instead of going to landfill.
The reports, prepared by Wasteco, use scaled weights where available. When weights are unavailable, they rely on audit information or industry averages. The results are useful management indicators, but they are not audited environmental accounts.
Organics and Cardboard Drove the Gains
Two material streams accounted for most of the improvement.
Organics increased by 34%, from 154 to 206 metric tonnes. Every building that reported organics in both years improved its capture. This broad progress suggests that training, clearer sorting, and better station design were having an effect across the portfolio.
Cardboard increased from 74 to 157 metric tonnes. Most of this gain came from 3180 Lakeshore Boulevard West, where reported cardboard grew from 19.24 to 98.80 metric tonnes. The building’s diversion rate rose from 23% to 59%.
Because the cardboard increase was concentrated in one location, it likely reflects a change in collection or consolidation rather than a sudden change in occupant behaviour.
This distinction matters. Broad improvement across several buildings may point to successful training, while a large change at one building may point to a service or infrastructure change that could be repeated elsewhere.
Separate Service Gaps from Behaviour Problems
Building-level reporting helped Humber identify an important issue at 3120 Lakeshore Boulevard West. The building recorded 0% diversion throughout 2024, 2025, and the first five months of 2026. No diverted stream appeared in its data.
Training and signage cannot improve a diversion rate if there is no collection stream available. In this case, the data did not indicate poor sorting. It indicated a service gap.
The experience led to a simple but important practice: before asking people to improve their sorting, confirm that every stream they are expected to use is available and collected consistently.
The data at 3170 Lakeshore Boulevard West tells a different story. Its diversion rate increased from 28% in 2024 to 53% in 2025 and reached 77% through May 2026. Monthly reports showed that cardboard collection disappeared for a period and later returned. The change in the rate therefore reflected the availability of an entire stream, not only a gradual improvement in sorting.
These two examples show why a campus average cannot provide the full answer. A low rate may reflect behaviour, but it may also reflect missing or inconsistent service.
Review the Data Every Month
Annual averages are useful, but they can hide operational changes. Monthly reporting helps teams identify unusual results while there is still time to respond. (See Table 2 below.)
| Period | Diversion result | Additional finding | What the data tells us |
|---|---|---|---|
| Central Receiving | |||
| 2023 | 40% | None recorded | Baseline year |
| 2024 | 43% | None recorded | +3 points year over year |
| 2025 | 45% | 161.81 metric tonnes of organics | +2 points; organics reached a record level |
| 2026 monthly review | Increase in waste identified | Investigation initiated before year end | Monthly reporting supported a faster operational response |
| North Campus Residence | |||
| 2024 | 8% | None recorded | Baseline year |
| 2025 | 12% | Organics increased by 55% | +4 points year over year |
| 3199 Lakeshore Boulevard West | |||
| 2025 | 27% | Monthly results ranged from 15% to 80% | Months with small material volumes can produce unusually high or low diversion rates |
One caution applies to residence data in particular: occupancy and activity shift through the academic year, so comparisons there should use equivalent periods rather than partial years.
A Practical Approach for Campus Facilities Teams
Humber’s experience can be applied through a straightforward cycle:
- Map the system. Follow material from disposal through collection, consolidation, and removal.
- Confirm that services exist. Verify that every expected stream is collected at each building and that service has not stopped.
- Train for each location. Provide a shared foundation, then address the materials and conditions found in each building.
- Listen to custodial team members. Create a clear process for reporting contamination, confusing stations, missing services, and prevention opportunities.
- Test focused improvements. Pilot centralized sorting, reusable containers, revised signage, or specialized collection where they are most likely to help.
- Review data in context. Examine rates alongside tonnage, material categories, occupancy, seasonal changes, and known operational events.
- Share what changed. Explain the results and tell employees what they should do next.
Building a Learning System
Humber’s progress came from connecting sustainability goals with facilities practices and frontline knowledge. Humber provided direction and brought together the teams responsible for sustainability, facilities, food service, and campus operations. BEST trained custodial employees and helped create a path for their observations to reach decision-makers. Regular reports showed where the system was working and where it needed attention.
The measurable result was a 42% increase in diverted material in one year. Seven of eight comparable buildings improved, and none declined.
The more lasting result is the learning system behind those numbers. Team members can identify a problem, report it, test a response, and use the data to see whether the change worked.
The most important checks are also among the simplest: confirm that a collection stream exists before training people to use it, and read every diversion rate beside the tonnage that produced it.
For facilities leaders, the message is clear. Treat the people closest to the work as a source of operational knowledge, and treat every diversion rate as the beginning of a question, not the end of the discussion.
Sources
- Wasteco. Material Diversion Report, 2023 through 2026. Individual annual reports prepared for Humber Polytechnic locations.
- BEST Service Pros. Waste Diversion Case Study: Humber Polytechnic. Unpublished internal project record.
About the Authors
Tessa Soltendieck holds a bachelor’s degree from McGill University and the McGill School of Environment, as well as a Master of Development Practice from the University of Waterloo’s School of Environment, Enterprise and Development. She is a Sustainability Manager at Humber Polytechnic in Toronto, Ontario. She can be reached at Tessa.Soltendieck@humber.ca.
Livia Valpassos holds a degree in Journalism and a postgraduate certificate in Marketing, both earned in Brazil, as well as a diploma in Business Management earned in Vancouver, British Columbia. She is the Director of Marketing at BEST Service Pros in Coquitlam, British Columbia. She can be reached at lvalpassos@best.ca.
Read the Full Issue
This article first appeared in the Fall 2026 issue of Facilities Manager, the magazine of APPA. Read the full Fall 2026 issue for more stories from member campuses.
The Magazine of APPA
Facilities Manager, Fall 2026
Explore the people, institutions, and partnerships shaping educational facilities through real stories from member campuses, Facilities Manager informs, connects, and inspires our community.
Have a project or lesson to share with your peers? Email publications@appa.org to submit to Facilities Manager.